Why Mayim Bialik Really Walked Off Jeopardy! - Did She Leave Or Was She Fired?

2023 came to a bit of a sour end for Mayim Bialik. The actress became the regular host of the daytime version of "Jeopardy!," a job she's been sharing with former winner Ken Jennings since December 2021. But she announced in an Instagram post in December 2023 that she would no longer be a part of the game show, turning her hosting duties over to Jennings full-time. "Sony has informed me that I will no longer be hosting the syndicated version of Jeopardy!," her statement read in part.

But did Bialik leave of her own volition? Or was she relieved of her duties by Sony? A statement released by Sony Pictures Television states that the choice was made to install Jennings as the sole host of the show's syndicated edition to establish a sense of continuity. The statement indicated that Bialik may continue to host "Celebrity Jeopardy!" in prime time on ABC, along with further specials from the brand. Yet a source reporting to The Messenger explained that Bialik was planning to return to the show after a long absence from the program and was surprised by Sony's decision.

The Ringer confirmed that Bialik's option was not picked up, meaning that her role with the syndicated show will end when the current season does, and that it was Sony Pictures Televison's choice to end Bialik's association with the daytime version of "Jeopardy!" But they also noted that multiple issues — from Bialik's tendency to draw controversial attention to the show, to her choice to support the WGA strike by refusing to cross the picket line to film episodes, to behind-the-scenes shuffling of opinions — may have contributed to the actor's tenure being terminated.

Mayim Bialik was anything but silent during her tenure as "Jeopardy!" host and found herself in a series of public pickles throughout her nearly three-year stint. First, comments she made about the #MeToo movement in a 2017 New York Times op-ed resurfaced. Bialik had released a statement on her X account (formerly known as Twitter) in 2017, further clarifying her stance and explaining that she did not intend to participate in victim blaming.

Then, her promotion of an allegedly intelligence-boosting supplement called Neuriva was questioned. A month after Bialik took part in commercials for the drug, its parent company was required to change promotional language regarding the product due to a class-action lawsuit. This resulted in old statements regarding her belief in delayed or withheld vaccinations for children, as recounted in her parenting book "Beyond the Sling," resurfacing. Biyalik has vociferously denied that she was anti-vaccine on her blog and in videos on her YouTube channel.

Most recently, Bialik's expression of support for the Israeli Defense Force on her Instagram while using phrases similar to those used on "Jeopardy!" has stirred up attention. Bialik had previously admitted to donating money to the IDF so that they might be able to purchase Kevlar vests.

At least one controversial choice directly kept her from her hosting duties. Bialik told Variety that she would not cross the picket line during the SAG-AFTRA strike, while Jennings continued to host the show. This has kept her away from the program since late May 2023. Per Matthew Belloni of Puck, the choice was not a popular one with Sony executives and may have further contributed to the choice to stick with Ken Jennings.

With Mayim Bialik off "Jeopardy!" for the majority of 2023, it was impossible, according to The Ringer, for producers to avoid comparing her performance as a host with Ken Jenning's work. While fans had initially warmed to Bialik's more polished delivery versus Jenning's, hosting solo for an extended period gave him the opportunity to hone his performance and his ratings ended up generally equaling or coming close to those of Bialik's episodes. And while Jennings has experienced controversies of his own, they are not as numerous or high profile as Bialik's.

Producers for the game show held a long talent hunt following Alex Trebek's death in 2021, and Bialik and Jennings were among the more popular guest hosts who filled in. Ironically, both Bialik and Jennings' "Jeopardy!" hirings ended up being steeped in negative public attention unrelated to their actual abilities, but they aren't alone in this. When series producer Mike Richards was selected to take over for Trebek in the fall of 2021, audiences rebelled after comments Richards made on a podcast resurfaced. He stepped down, and Bialik and Jennings were hired in his wake. But now it looks like Jennings will pilot the good ship "Jeopardy!" — at least the daytime version — solo.

As for Bialik, it appears that she's looking forward to a different sort of 2024. She posted on her Instagram on New Year's Eve 2023 that she hoped for a brighter year ahead. Time will tell if her wishes are granted.