"Criminal Minds" is definitely not short on creepy episodes, as it has its fair share of serial killers, psychopaths, and cannibals. Still, some episodes take a different route, steering away from the gruesome nastiness and toward more subtly haunting events.

The Season 7 episode "Heathridge Manor" dabbles in gothic horror, devil worship, and delusions. Its spectacularly unnerving ending also hints that the story isn’t over.

Online reaction to “Heathridge Manor” indicates that fans loved how creepy the episode was. Several Redditors agreed, saying they wished the story had continued past the single episode.